AI Rewrites Photoshop: ArtCraft Aims to Build an Open-Source Version and Rebuild the Internet

ArtCraft rewrites Photoshop with AI and open-sources it, proposing a grand vision to 'take back the internet,' but it faces three challenges: legal, quality, and community trust.
ArtCraft announced that it has rewritten Photoshop using AI and released it as open-source software. CEO Brandon Thomas has set out the grand goals of 'take back the internet' and 'rebuild everything,' suggesting that its roadmap may go far beyond image editing tools and involve a full-stack open-source ecosystem spanning the tool layer, platform layer, and community layer. The article analyzes AI's potential role in code generation, reverse engineering, and testing, while also pointing out that the project faces legal risks (copyright and patents), the quality threshold set by professional users, and community concerns about the 'black box' nature of AI-generated code. At present, the plan is still at the stage of a directional statement, but its approach offers new possibilities for the open-source community and, if successful, could change the balance of power between commercial software and open-source software.
An Ambitious Open-Source Plan
According to RSS sources, ArtCraft has rewritten Photoshop using AI technology and released it as open-source software. This sounds far-fetched—Photoshop, as Adobe's flagship product, has undergone decades of iteration and has a massive, complex codebase. But ArtCraft CEO Brandon Thomas is clearly not content with merely building a clone. His vision is far grander: "take back the internet."

This statement is worth pondering. The slogan "take back the internet" has appeared frequently in recent years among open-source communities, privacy advocates, and decentralization supporters, but coming from the CEO of a company rewriting commercial software with AI, it suggests that ArtCraft's roadmap may extend far beyond image editing tools.
What It Means to Rewrite Photoshop with AI
Photoshop's feature set is enormous: layer systems, masks, filters, color management, file format compatibility, performance optimization… Traditionally, rewriting such software would require a large engineering team and years of work. ArtCraft's choice to use AI to accelerate this process is itself noteworthy.
Although the original report did not disclose specific technical details, it can be inferred that AI may have played a role in code generation, reverse engineering, API mapping, and test case generation. Open-source release means anyone can view, modify, and distribute this "clone," directly challenging Adobe's subscription-based business model.
However, there is a key question here: What about the quality of AI-generated code, copyright compliance, and long-term maintainability? The open-source community tends to scrutinize such projects very strictly, and if legal or technical debt exists in the codebase, the project may struggle to gain broad trust.
Reverse engineering and API mapping are core technical steps when rewriting complex software. Reverse engineering refers to inferring a program's internal logic by analyzing its behavior, binary structure, or network communications without access to source code; API mapping involves mapping the original software's interface calls to functions in the new implementation to ensure compatibility. Traditionally, these two tasks rely on human expertise and extensive testing, making them time-consuming and error-prone. AI can play a supporting role here: for example, using large models to analyze decompiled code and generate semantic annotations, or automatically deriving function signatures through symbolic execution. But AI-generated mappings still require human verification, especially when patented algorithms or undisclosed file formats are involved, where legal risks and technical uncertainty rise significantly.
The Grand Narrative of "Rebuild Everything"
Brandon Thomas's ambition goes beyond image editing. The phrase "rebuild everything" suggests that ArtCraft may be attempting to build a full-stack open-source ecosystem from foundational tools to upper-layer applications. Combined with the slogan "take back the internet," this may mean:
- Tool layer: Rewrite mainstream commercial software with AI and provide open-source alternatives
- Platform layer: Build decentralized collaboration and distribution infrastructure
- Community layer: Attract developers and creators to co-build the ecosystem
This kind of "full-stack ambition" is uncommon in open-source history. Successful open-source projects usually focus on a single domain (such as Linux for operating systems and Blender for 3D creation), whereas simultaneously challenging multiple commercial software giants requires extremely strong resource integration capabilities and community mobilization power.

Challenges and Uncertainties
Despite the grand vision, the challenges facing ArtCraft cannot be ignored. The first is legal risk: "cloning" commercial software with AI may cross copyright and patent red lines, and Adobe's legal team will not sit idly by. The second is the quality threshold: professional users' reliance on Photoshop is built on decades of accumulated stability and workflows, and an open-source clone would need to reach considerable standards in compatibility and performance before it could be accepted.
The third is community trust: open-source projects require transparent governance and sustained maintenance commitments, and the "black box" nature of AI-generated code may raise doubts among contributors. Whether Brandon Thomas's "take back the internet" narrative can translate into actual community mobilization remains to be seen.
At present, ArtCraft's declaration looks more like a directional statement than a mature product roadmap. But indeed, the very idea of rewriting mainstream software with AI and open-sourcing it offers the open-source community a new possibility—if successful, it could change the balance of power between commercial software and open-source software.
Copyright and patent red lines are especially complex in software cloning scenarios. Copyright protects the expression of code, not functional ideas, so a completely independent rewrite (clean-room development) usually does not constitute copyright infringement; however, if AI training data includes the original software's code or documentation, the generated output may be deemed a derivative work. Patents protect the technical solution itself—for example, certain image processing algorithms in Photoshop may be patent-protected, and even a code rewrite could fall within the scope of the claims. In addition, the compatibility of open-source licenses and the copyright ownership of AI-generated code (currently undetermined in the laws of many countries) are all potential legal minefields. Companies such as Adobe have historically maintained market position through patent litigation and licensing agreements, and if ArtCraft touches core functionality, legal conflict is almost inevitable.
Signals Worth Watching
For those following AI programming and open-source tools, ArtCraft's moves are worth tracking. The questions it raises are valuable: Can AI truly lower the marginal cost of rewriting complex software? Can the open-source model achieve leapfrog development with the help of AI? Behind the slogan "take back the internet," is there a substantive technical roadmap or merely a marketing narrative?
The answers to these questions will determine whether ArtCraft becomes a footnote in open-source history or ushers in a new mode of software production.
Background Supplement
The difficulty of building a full-stack open-source ecosystem lies in the coupling and governance between layers. The tool layer needs to continuously track feature updates in commercial software, the platform layer must solve decentralized identity, data synchronization, and content distribution protocols, and the community layer depends on contributor incentives and transparent decision-making mechanisms. Historically, open-source projects covering multiple layers at once (such as GNOME and KDE) have often required foundation support and years of accumulation. If ArtCraft wants to use AI to accelerate full-stack rebuilding, it must address issues such as cross-layer interface standardization, security auditing, and sustainable funding models; otherwise, the grand narrative may easily remain at the level of slogans.
One-line Summary
ArtCraft rewrites Photoshop with AI and open-sources it, proposing a grand vision to "take back the internet," but it faces three challenges: legal, quality, and community trust.
Paragraph Summary
ArtCraft announced that it has rewritten Photoshop using AI technology and released it as open-source software. CEO Brandon Thomas has set out the grand goals of "take back the internet" and "rebuild everything," suggesting that its roadmap may go far beyond image editing tools and involve a full-stack open-source ecosystem spanning the tool layer, platform layer, and community layer. The article analyzes AI's potential role in code generation, reverse engineering, and testing, while also pointing out that the project faces legal risks (copyright and patents), the quality threshold set by professional users, and community concerns about the "black box" nature of AI-generated code. At present, the plan is still at the stage of a directional statement, but its approach offers new possibilities for the open-source community and, if successful, could change the balance of power between commercial software and open-source software.
Related articles

How Fast Can AI Become an Expert? Lessons from Napoleon and Rockefeller
From Napoleon's victories at 27 to Rockefeller running a major refinery at 25, we explore why AI can accumulate experience far faster than humans: reading a company's entire history in days, reaching top performance in months, and the real bottleneck of serial feedback.

US Air Traffic Control Keeps Breaking Down—Can Canada's Model Fix It?
A botched copper cable upgrade grounded thousands of US flights. Vox analysis: aging equipment, overworked controllers, and the FAA's annual funding battles are the root causes—Canada's 1996 nonprofit ATC model offers a way out.

Why Can't an AI with 20 PhDs Get Anything Done in the Enterprise?
OpenAI co-founder Greg Brockman uses the "20 PhDs with no data access" analogy to reveal the core bottleneck of enterprise AI: business context and permission guardrails are both essential. This article covers his conversation with the Databricks CEO and the Genie product's implementation approach.