Unverified70% confidenceBenchmarkExact time
The results of the NeurIPS 2022 consistency experiment showed that approximately 50% of papers received completely different accept/reject decisions between the two groups of reviewers
2
Sources
70%
Confidence
Long-term
Relevance
8/7/2026
First Seen
Sources
Related Claims
Unverified多项实证研究表明顶级会议的接收决定存在显著随机性，估计约50%的被接收论文在重新评审时可能会被拒绝79% similarUnverifiedWhen the same paper is given to different reviewers, the conclusions of acceptance and rejection are often split roughly evenly.78% similarVerifiedIn 2014, the NeurIPS program committee conducted a review consistency experiment in which approximately 10% (about 166 papers) were reviewed by two independent program committees, and the two groups' acceptance decisions were only approximately 57% consistent.76% similarUnverifiedPapers receiving scores of 2/3/3 at NeurIPS are almost certain to be rejected, with the statistical probability of entering the acceptance range being below 5%.74% similarUnverifiedNeurIPS主会论文经过双盲同行评审，接收率通常在20-25%之间72% similar
Cite This Claim
Stable URI
https://kongchang.com/claim/700805API
curl https://kongchang.com/api/v1/knowledge/claims/700805MCP
get_claim(id=700805)